ContractsNovember 16, 20266 min read

Five Contract Clauses That Can Create Uninsured Professional Liability for Your Firm

Your E&O policy covers negligence, not every promise you sign. Five common contract clauses can leave your firm with liability no policy will pay, and most of them can be negotiated.

By Provident Financial Group

Five contract clauses routinely create liability that a professional liability policy will not pay: broad indemnification, warranties of results, liquidated damages, waivers of the ordinary standard of care, and unlimited liability with no cap. Each one makes your firm responsible for more than its own negligence, and errors and omissions policies are generally written to cover negligence and not much else.

Client contracts have grown longer and more one-sided, especially when a small consulting, IT or accounting firm signs a large company's master services agreement. A clause that reads like boilerplate can quietly shift risk onto your firm that no carrier agreed to take. These clauses are usually negotiable, especially once you can explain that the language is uninsured.

How E&O policies treat contractual liability

Most professional liability policies contain a contractual liability exclusion. The policy will generally not pay for liability you took on by agreement that you would not have had under the law anyway. If a client could sue you for negligence regardless of what the contract said, the policy typically responds. If the only reason you owe the client money is a promise you made in the contract, it often does not.

Many policies soften this with an exception for liability you would have had in the absence of the contract, which keeps ordinary negligence claims covered even when a contract is involved. The clauses below reach beyond it. Some carriers offer endorsements that broaden contractual coverage, so reading your own policy's exclusion and its exceptions is the starting point for every contract review.

Clause one: broad indemnification

An indemnification clause requires you to defend and reimburse the client for losses. A narrow version, limited to losses caused by your negligence, generally lines up with what E&O covers. A broad version requires you to indemnify the client for any claim "arising out of" your work, regardless of fault, and sometimes for the client's own negligence.

That broader obligation is pure contractual liability. If the client is sued for something only loosely connected to your project and demands that you pay their defense costs, your carrier may decline because you never would have owed that money without the clause.

Negotiate indemnification down to claims "to the extent caused by" your negligent acts, errors or omissions, and ask for it to be mutual. Many clients accept this once they understand that broader language is uninsurable and therefore only as good as your firm's balance sheet.

Clause two: warranties and promised results

Professional services are judged by the standard of care, meaning whether you performed as a reasonably competent professional would. A warranty clause replaces that measure with a promise: the software will be free of defects, the campaign will deliver a stated number of leads, the tax position will survive audit. If the promise is not met, you are liable whether or not you were careless.

E&O policies are generally built around the standard of care and often exclude express warranties and representations of outcome. A firm that signs one is, in effect, self-insuring the gap between competent work and perfect results.

Replace outcome language with process language. Agree to perform services "in a professional and workmanlike manner consistent with industry standards," and offer to re-perform deficient work as the exclusive remedy for a warranty breach.

Clause three: liquidated damages

Liquidated damages clauses set a fixed sum you owe for a specified failure, often a missed deadline or a service-level miss, without the client having to prove actual loss.

Because the payment is owed by agreement rather than by a finding of negligence, many E&O policies treat liquidated damages as uninsured contractual penalties. Some policies carve them back if the amount does not exceed what the client could have proven in actual damages, but do not assume that.

Try to remove the clause, or cap the total at a small percentage of fees, and limit it to delays within your control.

Clause four: waiving the standard of care

Some contracts raise the bar instead of setting a dollar figure. Language requiring you to perform to "the highest professional standards," or to use "best efforts" replaces the reasonable-professional standard with something stricter or entirely subjective.

Insurers generally underwrite E&O on the ordinary standard of care, so a claim alleging that you fell short of a heightened contractual standard, while meeting the ordinary one, may fall outside the policy. Strike "highest" and "best," and substitute "reasonable" or "generally accepted" wherever the standard is described.

Clause five: unlimited liability and the additional insured request

A limitation of liability clause caps what you can owe the client, often at the fees paid under the agreement. Contracts that delete the cap, or that exclude whole categories of loss from it, expose your firm to damages well above your policy limit. Insurance pays up to the limit; everything beyond it is yours.

Negotiate a cap tied to fees or to your E&O limit, and keep consequential damages, such as the client's lost profits, excluded on both sides. When a client refuses any cap, involve your agent before signing, because higher limits may be available.

A related request often arrives with the contract: the client asks to be named as an additional insured on your professional liability policy. Unlike general liability, most E&O policies do not permit additional insureds, because the policy covers your professional acts, not the client's.

When to send the contract to your agent

Send any agreement to your agent before signing when it includes indemnification broader than your own negligence, a warranty of results, liquidated damages, a heightened standard of care, no liability cap, or a request for additional insured status. Provident Financial Group is an independent agency that quotes multiple carriers, and we review client contracts against the actual policy language so you know what is covered before you commit. Call (866) 964-6660 or start a quote online.

Frequently asked questions

Does professional liability insurance cover indemnification clauses?

Generally only to the extent the indemnity covers your own negligence. Most E&O policies exclude liability assumed by contract that you would not have had otherwise, so indemnifying a client for their own negligence or for any claim merely connected to your work is often uninsured.

Can my client be an additional insured on my E&O policy?

Usually not. Professional liability policies cover the insured firm's professional services, and most carriers do not add clients as insureds the way general liability carriers do. If a client insists, your agent can explain the distinction and provide a certificate evidencing your coverage and limits.

What if the client will not negotiate any of these clauses?

You can still sign, but do so knowing the risk is uninsured and priced accordingly. Ask your agent whether higher limits or a contractual liability endorsement are available, document the client's refusal, and consider whether the engagement is worth the exposure.

This article is general information, not insurance or legal advice. Coverage terms vary by policy, carrier, and state — talk with a licensed agent about your business.

Found this useful? Add US Professional Insure as a preferred source on Google.

Ready to see your options?

One application. Up to 10 competing quotes. Answer a few questions and we will shop your business to our A-rated carrier network, then a licensed agent walks you through the options.

Get my quotes 1-866-964-6660

Mon – Fri, 8:00am – 6:00pm ET

Get quotes Call1-866-964-6660